Skip to content

Guide

Keystone pricing: what it means, the formula and when to use it

Keystone pricing means retail is double wholesale: a 100% markup and a 50% margin. Formula, worked examples, triple keystone and when 2x is wrong.

CatalogKite TeamUpdated 8 min read

Keystone pricing is a retail pricing rule: a store sells a product for twice what it paid for it. A candle bought from the maker at $14 goes on the shelf at $28. That is a 100% markup on the wholesale price and a 50% margin for the store. This guide explains what keystone means on both sides of the counter, gives the formula in both directions, explains why double and triple keystone get confused, and shows how to test whether keystone works for one of your own products.

What keystone pricing means

Keystone is a convention among retailers, mostly independent stores that sell gifts, fashion, jewelry, home goods, beauty and stationery. A buyer who asks "is it keystone?" is asking one thing: is your suggested retail price (MSRP) at least double your wholesale price?

You will see the same idea under several names:

  • Keystone pricing or the keystone method: retail price = wholesale price × 2.
  • Keystone markup: a 100% markup on what the store paid.
  • Keystone margin: the 50% of the retail price that the store keeps.

They all describe the same sale. The store pays $14, sells at $28 and keeps $14.

Keystone is the store's rule, but it matters just as much to the brand. You publish both the wholesale price and the MSRP, so you decide whether a store can reach keystone before the buyer has even seen the product.

Where the name comes from is not well documented. The story told most often traces it to The Keystone, a US jewelry trade magazine of the late 1800s. We could not find a primary source for that, so treat it as trade lore.

The keystone pricing formula

To findFormulaExample
Retail price from wholesaleretail = wholesale × 2$14.00 × 2 = $28.00
Wholesale price from retailwholesale = retail ÷ 2$28.00 ÷ 2 = $14.00
The store's markup(retail − wholesale) ÷ wholesale$14.00 ÷ $14.00 = 100%
The store's margin(retail − wholesale) ÷ retail$14.00 ÷ $28.00 = 50%

A store uses the first row: it doubles your wholesale price. A brand uses the second: halve the shelf price the market will bear to find the most a keystone store will pay you.

Stores often round the result. A $13.75 wholesale price doubles to $27.50, and a store may tag it $27.50, $28 or $29. If you publish a rounded MSRP yourself, you make that decision for them. The wholesale price calculator applies keystone, or any other multiple, to your own numbers.

Keystone markup and keystone margin are the same thing

A 100% markup and a 50% margin sound like different deals. They are the same $14, measured against different numbers. Markup divides the profit by what the store paid. Margin divides it by what the customer paid.

The confusion costs money in one common case. A new brand reads that stores "need 50%" and sets its MSRP at wholesale plus 50%, so $14 becomes $21. That is a 50% markup, which is only a 33.3% margin, and a buyer sees at once that the product is not keystone.

This table shows what each retail multiple gives the store, using a $14 wholesale price.

Retail multipleMarkup on wholesaleStore marginRetail price
1.5×50%33.3%$21.00
1.8×80%44.4%$25.20
2× (keystone)100%50.0%$28.00
2.2×120%54.5%$30.80
2.5×150%60.0%$35.00
3×200%66.7%$42.00

If someone quotes you a percentage and you need the other one, the markup calculator converts both ways.

Double keystone and triple keystone

Triple keystone commonly means that the retail price is three times the wholesale price: a 200% markup and a 66.7% margin for the store. You see it on low-cost items priced on perceived value, such as some fashion jewelry.

Double keystone has no agreed meaning, and published definitions of both terms disagree. Many count multiples, which makes triple keystone 3× and leaves double keystone unclear. Some count markups instead: keystone is one 100% markup, double keystone is a 200% markup (3×) and triple keystone is a 300% markup (4×).

So when a buyer, a sales rep or a supplier uses either term, ask for the multiple as a number. "Retail is three times wholesale" cannot be misread.

Why stores need half the price

Fifty percent looks generous until you see what it pays for. Out of its margin a store covers rent, wages, card fees, shipping from you to its door, displays, theft, damage and every item it has to mark down to clear. What is left is its profit.

Here is keystone for a store that buys ten candles at $14 and has to discount the last three by 30%.

LineUnitsPrice eachTotal
Sold at full price7$28.00$196.00
Sold at 30% off3$19.60$58.80
Sales10$254.80
Paid to you10$14.00$140.00
Left to cover the store's costs$114.80

The 50% margin on paper is 45.1% at the register ($114.80 ÷ $254.80). If shipping added $1 per candle to the store's cost, it would be 41.1%. That is why buyers resist anything below keystone, and why some want more than 2× on products they expect to mark down.

Keystone from the brand's side

For a brand, keystone sets a ceiling. Start from the shelf price and work down.

  1. Find the shelf price. Look at comparable products in the kind of store you want to be in. Say candles like yours sell for about $28.
  2. Halve it. A keystone store will pay you at most $14.
  3. Take off your margin. What is left is the most the product can cost you to make. At a 50% margin that is $14 × (1 − 0.50) = $7.00.
Your target margin at wholesaleThe most your candle can cost
40%$8.40
50%$7.00
60%$5.60

At a 50% margin on both sides, the retail price is four times your cost. That gives you a quick test for any product idea: divide the likely shelf price by four. If you cannot make it for that, with your own labor counted, wholesale will be tight.

Two more rules. First, sell at MSRP or above on your own website and market booth, because a store cannot compete with a supplier who discounts. Second, if you sell through a distributor, a middleman who resells to stores, the store still expects keystone, so the distributor's share comes out of your side. The guide to pricing products for wholesale builds a full cost per unit and a distributor tier step by step.

When keystone is the wrong multiple

Keystone is a habit, not a law. These are the usual exceptions.

SituationWhat usually happens
Food and drink sold through grocery storesStores often work on a 30–40% margin, about 1.4× to 1.7× wholesale, and make it up on volume
Fine jewelry and other items with a high material costRetail is often 1.6× to 1.8× wholesale, because doubling would price the product out of its market
Accessories and leather goodsMany boutiques look for 2.2× to 2.5×
Products shoppers can price-check onlineThe going price sets retail, so the store's margin is whatever your wholesale price leaves
Heavy or bulky goodsShipping is a large part of the store's cost, so buyers ask for free shipping above an order size, or for a better price
Trade and industrial suppliesSold from a list price less a trade discount, not from an MSRP

Ranges like these vary by country and by store, so check them with buyers in your own category before you print a price.

How to test keystone on one product

Take a stoneware mug that costs you $11 to make. Similar mugs sell for $32 to $38.

  1. Pick an MSRP inside the range: $36.
  2. Halve it for the keystone wholesale price: $18.
  3. Subtract your cost: $18 − $11 = $7 profit per mug.
  4. Divide by the wholesale price: $7 ÷ $18 = 38.9% margin.
  5. Compare it with your target. If you need 50%, this mug does not get there at keystone.

You then have four ways out, and each one costs something.

OptionWholesaleMSRPYour marginStore marginThe catch
Raise the MSRP$22.00$44.0050.0%50.0%Above what similar mugs sell for
Cut your cost to $9.00$18.00$36.0050.0%50.0%Needs cheaper materials, bigger batches or less labor
Offer less than keystone (1.8×)$20.00$36.0045.0%44.4%Still short of 50%, and some buyers will pass
Sell it direct onlyNone$36.0069.4% before selling costsNoneNo store volume

No row is the right answer for everyone. A brand with a strong following can hold a $44 price. A potter working alone may keep this mug for markets and wholesale a simpler one.

Show keystone on your line sheet

A line sheet is the price sheet a wholesale buyer orders from; what is a line sheet explains it in full. Many buyers check the margin first. Put the wholesale price and the MSRP in adjacent columns on every line, so the multiple is visible without a calculator. A price list works the same way: this furniture price list has both columns. If a product is not keystone, show both prices anyway and be ready to say why. Say who pays for shipping as well, because the store's real cost is your price plus shipping.

In CatalogKite, wholesale price and MSRP are separate fields on each product, and a line sheet prints them side by side.

Put wholesale and MSRP side by side in a line sheet PDF or a link buyers can order from.

Make a line sheet

Common mistakes

  • Doubling your cost and calling it retail. A store that takes its usual half would pay you exactly what the product cost you to make, so it can only be sold direct.
  • Saying "50%" without saying of what. Say "50% margin" or "100% markup", or give the multiple.
  • Ignoring shipping. A store that pays the shipping on a keystone product earns less than 50%.
  • Treating MSRP as an order. It is a suggestion. Stores set their own prices, and the rules on requiring a resale price differ by country.

Keystone pricing checklist

  • Shelf price range checked for each product
  • MSRP chosen and rounded
  • Wholesale price set at half of MSRP, or at another multiple you can state
  • Your margin worked out from full cost, labor included
  • A fix chosen for each product below your target margin
  • Wholesale and MSRP side by side on the line sheet
  • Shipping terms stated
  • Your own retail prices at MSRP or above

For the terms that sit around the price, such as minimums, net 30 and lead times, see wholesale terms explained.

Written by the CatalogKite Team. Last updated . Spotted something out of date? Tell us at the email address in the footer.

Your next catalog is ten minutes away.

Open the maker, add a few products and download a PDF. No signup, no credit card.